Travellers lose appeal over site near Somerset gigafactory

5
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

A travellers' site near Somerset's new 'gigafactory' may have to be torn down following a failed appeal.

Charlie Barney and J. Birch applied in December 2025 for retrospective planning permission for a travellers' site which they had constructed west of Batch Lane in Puriton, between the M5 and the Gravity enterprise zone.

Somerset Council refused the plans in February 2025, prompting the applicants to lodge an appeal with the Planning Inspectorate in a bid to legitimate the development.

But planning inspector Laura Cuthbert has now upheld the council's decision - meaning enforcement action could be taken against the applicants and their families if the land is not returned to its original state.

The site lies to the north of the main built-up area of Puriton, a stone's throw from junction 23 of the motorway and the former railway line which once served the Royal Ordnance Factory where the gigafactory now stands.

Retrospective plans for travellers' site on Batch Lane in Puriton (Image: Mark Simmonds Planning Services)

Two pitches are provided within the facility, including day room, static caravans and space for a touring caravan, all on hard-standing ground with a gated access onto Batch Lane.

The entire site lies within flood zone 3a on the official Environment Agency (EA) flood maps - meaning it is considered at relatively high risk of flooding.

Ms Cuthbert visited the site on August 5 and published her final ruling before the council's planning committee north (which handles major applications within the former Sedgemoor area) met in Bridgwater on Tuesday afternoon (September 8).

She observed that the development which had been undertaken on Batch Lane "does not fully accord" with the original plans, noting the day rooms and static caravans had been placed in different locations and the day rooms were "of a different design and scale" than had been intended.

While she acknowledged that "the gypsy status of the appellant and the wider group is not in dispute", she said that the site's location made the residents "highly vulnerable" to localised flooding.

She elaborated: "The EA advises that a residual tidal breach event could result in flood depths of up to one metre at the site, posing a significant risk to life and making evacuation difficult and potentially unsafe.

"The EA also raises concerns regarding the safety of future occupiers during flood events, particularly in relation to access to and from the site.

"The sole means of access to the site is via Batch Road to the east, which is also located within flood zone 3a and would itself be susceptible to flooding."

Ms Cuthbert said that "no detailed plans" had been provided to demonstrate a safe route for evacuating residents in the event of serious flooding, arguing that there was "insufficient evidence" that they could reach higher ground in an emergency.

She said: "I am not satisfied that future occupiers would be able to reach a place of safety during a flood event.

Travellers' site on Batch Lane in Puriton (Image: Google Maps)

"Given the highly vulnerable nature of the proposed development, I find that the safety of future occupiers would be jeopardised.

"Accordingly, the proposal would not be safe for its lifetime, taking account of the vulnerability of its occupants."

Ms Cuthbert said there would be only "limited harm" from building in this part of the countryside, given that a separate, more established gypsy and traveller site is currently in place next door.

She also acknowledged the high demand for travellers' pitches in Somerset, with the most recent assessment in February stating that 261 pitches were needed across the county.

But despite this "clear and pressing need", she ultimately concluded that the risk posed to residents outweighed any benefits of allowing the facility to remain in place.

Agratas Battery Storage project in construction near Bridgwater (Image: Agratas)

She concluded: "The proposal would provide accommodation for two gypsy and traveller families, including dependent children.

"The development would provide secure and settled accommodation while enabling the families to maintain their cultural identity, established way of life and close family support networks.

"However, it is a well-established principle that each planning application and appeal must be determined on its own merits and on the basis of the evidence before the decision-maker.

"Somerset Council has advised that, following a change in stance in January 2026 through discussions with the EA, it was concluded that gypsy and traveller development in flood zone 3 in particular is not supportable.

"The determining issue is whether the proposed development has been shown to be safe for its lifetime, taking account of flood risk and the vulnerability of its intended occupants.

Somerset Council's headquarters at County Hall in Taunton (Image: Somerset County Gazette)

"I am not satisfied that this has been demonstrated."

Following the dismissal of this appeal, the council is within its right to undertake enforcement action against the occupants if they do not return the land to its original condition within a given time-frame.

The council has struggled with high levels of demand on its existing enforcement team, with senior planning officers admitting in January that they were heavily reliant on staff sourced as far afield as Staffordshire to look into local cases.

The council has not confirmed whether any specific enforcement action will be taken against the Batch Lane site in the near-future.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos