Decision over 750 new Bridgwater homes near M5 delayed

14
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

A decision over plans for 750 new homes near the M5 has been delayed for several months over concerns about affordable housing and local NHS funding.

Edward Ware (Bridgwater) Ltd. put forward plans in early-2023 to deliver the major development - which will also include a new primary school and community hub - between Bower Lane and the motorway at the eastern edge of the town.

The plans came before Somerset Council's planning committee north in Bridgwater on Tuesday afternoon (July 14), with planning officers recommending approval despite only five per cent of the intended homes being affordable.

But after nearly three hours of deliberation, the committee voted to defer a decision to allow for more consultation over the funding of local health services and to see whether additional low-cost housing could be delivered under the proposals.

Here's everything you need to know:

What is planned at the site?

View of planned site of 750 Bridgwater homes from M5 footbridge (Image: Daniel Mumby)

The land east of Bower Lane and Dunwear Lane in Bridgwater is identified for future housing growth within the Sedgemoor Local Plan, providing "around 1,200 homes" by 2032.

Countryside Partnerships is currently delivering the Strawberry Grange development of 260 homes on the north side of the A372 Westonzoyland Road, which is accessed from a recently-constructed roundabout.

To the south of the A372, outline planning permission is in place for 530 homes on the Folletts Farm site - with Barratt Homes putting forward detailed plans for the first phase (comprising 178 properties) in mid-February.

The Edward Ware site lies between the Strawberry Grange estate and Polden Bower special needs school, a stone's throw from Bridgwater Community Hospital and the town's new NHS diagnostic centre.

Under the plans, a new primary school and community hub will be delivered on land near the Bower Inn, with significant areas of green space on either side.

The plans would see housing delivered in three phases, starting from the northern end, as well as the completion of a spine road linking the A39 Bath Road to Westonzoyland Road via Strawberry Grange.

Bower Lane will be largely closed off to traffic, providing a green corridor for pedestrians and cyclists and improving existing connections to the Whitfield Road play area.

Why will so few of the homes be affordable?

Plans for 750 homes, primary school and community hub east of Bower Lane in Bridgwater (Image: Thrive Architects)

Under normal circumstances, any new development of ten homes or more within the former Sedgemoor area must deliver 30 per cent affordable housing - which in this instance would equate to 225 properties.

However, the developer has argued that the new housing estate would not be viable if it had to deliver this level, citing the cost of delivering the spine road and the land for the primary school.

While the developer is not providing any additional funding to construct the school, or any money at all for local NHS doctors' surgeries or dentists, the council has insisted on the development providing around £1m towards improved walking and cycling links from the new homes.

Furthermore, the council is requested £937,500 towards the cost of the now-completed Dunball roundabout upgrade - funding which would otherwise have to be met through external borrowing.

Under these circumstances, Edward Ware has offered that only five per cent of the new homes will be affordable - the equivalent of 38 properties.

However, this could rise if other contributions can be reduced or funding can be secured from central government via Homes England.

What do local people think?

View of the Strawberry Grange estate in Bridgwater from M5 footbridge (Image: Daniel Mumby)

Numerous local residents made their displeasure about the plans plainly known when the planning committee north met in Bridgwater on Tuesday afternoon (July 14).

Sarah Baker from the East Bridgwater Urban Wildlife Group) said that the development would overwhelm the town's waste water treatment facilities, which would not be upgraded for several years.

She explained: "Bridgwater's water recycling centre reached treatment capacity before 2024.

"There were 34 storm overflow spills during the 2024 bathing season alone, and significant waste water investment is not planned until at least 2030.

"You have not been provided with sufficient evidence that the waste water infrastructure can support this increase in housing numbers without unacceptable cumulative impacts."

Carole Edmunds, who sits on Bridgwater Town Council, argued that the new primary school would not be big enough to meet local need.

She said: "This development will generate 315 new pupils for primary and early years education, out of a total of 663 pupils for the East Bridgwater allocation.

"A large primary school will be needed, but the land planned for a school within this site only provides space for 420 pupils.

"Unlucky children not in the local school will be sent out to the as-yet-unbuilt school at Wilstock. Very young children will face a nine-mile round trip, which is impractical and undesirable.

"Polden Bower school is already operating at 30 per cent above its baseline capacity - it is bursting at the seams."

Entrance to Polden Bower Special School on Bower Lane in Bridgwater (Image: Daniel Mumby)

Dr Liz Parfitt, who lives in Westonzoyland, argued the design of the spine road would not be safe for pedestrians and cyclists, and warned that the new road would merely add to existing traffic congestion in the town.

She said: "The proposed spine road appears to prioritise the needs of vehicles over those of non-motorised users, risking high-speed traffic in an urban environment.

"The Bower Lane and Dunwear Lane junctions form a bottleneck that is wholly inadequate to cope with the increased traffic converging on it from the A39 Bath Road, the Gravity site and the M5."

Liz Browne from Bridgwater Without Parish Council - who works as a primary care nurse - said it was absurd that the development would provide no funding for the town's numerous GP surgeries.

She said: "Bridgwater's GP practices have unanimously declared that they cannot absorb any increase in numbers, and that staff and patients would be put at risk without appropriate mitigation.

Liz Browne, pictured in May 2023, has been pushing for more NHS funding in BridgwaterLiz Browne, pictured in May 2023, has been pushing for more NHS funding in Bridgwater (Image: Daniel Mumby)

"Waiting times are already clinically unacceptable, creating adverse consequences for secondary care and worsening health outcomes for the population.

"Bridgwater has higher than average cases of respiratory illness. Why is there no air quality data from the M5 corridor available (i.e. from air pollution caused by frequently standing traffic)?

"To approve this will put profit before people and create chaos for generations.
Bridgwater deserves better."

What did the councillors say?

Cllr Diogo Rodrigues said the changes, introduced as part of the Celebration Mile improvements, have caused longer journeys and congestion.Councillor Diogo Rodrigues (Conservative, Bridgwater East and Bawdrip) (Image: Supplied)

Councillor Diogo Rodrigues (whose Bridgwater East and Bawdrip division includes the site) said the plans were wholly inadequate when it came to meeting Bridgwater's burgeoning need for low-cost housing.

He said: "Nobody disputes that Bridgwater needs more homes - I certainly don't. But we need the right homes, and that includes homes local people can actually afford.

"Social rent remains the most acute housing need in Somerset. You are being asked to approve one of the largest housing estates in Bridgwater with only 38 affordable homes.

"Communities are built on more than bricks and mortar - they're built on affordable homes, the schools, the healthcare, places for children to play and infrastructure that keeps pace with growth.

"If you have to water things down to just make the homes viable, our planning policies are not the problem, it’s the development itself."

Councillor Gill Slocombe (Conservative, Bridgwater West)Councillor Gill Slocombe (Conservative, Bridgwater West) (Image: Daniel Mumby)

Councillor Gill Slocombe (Conservative, Bridgwater West) described the developer as "greedy" and said she could not support such a low level of affordable homes within such a large site.

She said: "I don't like the cake, I don't like how it’s sliced - the cake's just not big enough.

"I cannot support an application that does not deliver 30 per cent affordable homes - we are desperate for homes.

"It feels to me that the developer are being greedy - they want all the housing but don't actually want to give anything back.

Planned site of 750 Bridgwater homes, seen from Bower Lane (Image: Daniel Mumby)

"The NHS should be given more time - they are on a ten-year plan and probably can't see what projects they want to do right now."

Councillor Mike Murphy (Liberal Democrat, Burnham-on-Sea North) said this was "one of the worst cases I've seen" regarding the level of affordable housing.

He added: "These people are going to try and get as much out of this site as possible – and I don’t think that’s acceptable."

What happens next?

Bower Lane in Bridgwater (Image: Daniel Mumby)

The committee voted to defer a decision on the application for at least three months.

Planning officers will now negotiate with NHS Somerset and the developer to see whether additional affordable housing and funding for NHS services can be secured - with a revised proposal coming back to the committee before Christmas.

Under the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025, any development of 150 homes or more which is refused by the council is automatically referred to the government, which may choose to 'call in' the decision.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos